How To Make Your Burned Cooking Sheets Look New Again


If you’ve ever peered at your baking or cookie sheets and cringed at the sight of stubborn stains, you’re not alone. Over time, these kitchen essentials can lose their luster and accumulate unsightly yellow and brown stains from baked-on sugar, oils, and other residues. While standard cleaning methods may not always cut it, fear not – we’ve got a few tricks up our sleeves to help you rejuvenate those tarnished sheets. In this guide, we’ll explore three innovative approaches that promise to bring your baking sheets back to life.

Method 1: Hydrogen Peroxide and Baking Soda You Will Need:

  • Hydrogen Peroxide
  • Baking Soda
  • Coarse Rag or Sponge


  1. Begin by generously spreading a layer of baking soda onto the affected baking sheet.
  2. Pour hydrogen peroxide over the baking soda, creating a fizzy reaction that aids in lifting stains.
  3. Add more baking soda on top of the hydrogen peroxide for added cleaning power.
  4. Let this dynamic duo sit for a couple of hours, allowing them to work their magic.
  5. Afterward, wipe and gently scrub the sheet with a coarse cloth or sponge.

Method 2: Bar Keepers Friend and Steel Wool An alternative approach, suggested by experts, involves using Bar Keepers Friend and steel wool to tackle those stubborn stains. Please note that a thorough post-cleaning rinse is essential to ensure no residue remains on your baking sheet.

Method 3: Ammonia in a Bag Clean Brown Wren, a home care aficionado, shared an effective method that involves ammonia and a plastic garbage bag. Here’s how to bring back the shine to your baking sheets.

You Will Need:

  • Ammonia
  • Steel Wool
  • Plastic Garbage Bag


  1. Place the stained baking sheets inside a plastic bag and add approximately 1/2 cup of ammonia to the bag.
  2. Seal the bag tightly and let it bask in the sun for an entire day. During this time, the ammonia will work to soften and break down the stubborn oils and grime.
  3. After a day of soaking, open the bag and use steel wool to scrub the baking sheet. The oil and gunk should come off with relative ease.
  4. Thoroughly rinse the sheet to remove any remaining ammonia residue.

A word of caution: When working with ammonia, take safety precautions. Keep it out of reach of children, avoid inhaling its fumes, and wear protective gloves and eyewear.

Before applying any of these methods to your baking sheets, it’s wise to test a small area to ensure they won’t damage the sheet’s surface.


There you have it – three unique and effective methods to rejuvenate your baking sheets, each with its own charm. Whether you choose the hydrogen peroxide and baking soda fizz, Bar Keepers Friend and steel wool duo, or the ammonia in a bag technique, rest assured that these innovative approaches can help restore your beloved baking sheets to their former glory. Say goodbye to those unsightly stains, and let your baking sheets shine once more. Have you tried any of these methods or discovered your own secret to success? Share your experiences and insights with us.