How To Make An Old-School Southern Tomato Sandwich


Indulging in the nostalgia of comforting, childhood meals is a timeless joy. Today, I’m excited to share a classic recipe that transports me back to the simple pleasures of growing up, especially for those who have Southern roots. The epitome of culinary simplicity, the Southern tomato sandwich remains an enduring symbol of comfort.

This uncomplicated recipe demands just a handful of staple ingredients:

  • White bread
  • Fresh tomatoes
  • Mayonnaise
  • Salt and pepper

Choosing the right tomatoes is key to elevating this humble sandwich. Opt for tomatoes that strike the perfect balance between ripe and firm. While I personally lean towards the robust flavor of beefsteak tomatoes, feel free to embrace your preferred variety.

To add a subtle twist, I like to lightly toast the slices of white bread, although some enthusiasts may prefer theirs untoasted. The star of the show is, of course, the tomato – sliced into thick, juicy rounds and seasoned with a generous pinch of salt and pepper. A modest layer of mayonnaise on both slices of bread serves as the glue, bringing the elements together seamlessly.

And there you have it – a genuine Southern tomato sandwich, evoking the essence of simplicity and tradition. Sure, I appreciate the complexities of a gourmet BLT or a tomato grilled cheese adorned with fresh basil. But when it comes to capturing the true spirit of Southern comfort, nothing beats this cherished, unassuming recipe.

So, whether you’re relishing the memories of your Southern upbringing or discovering the charm of this classic for the first time, savor the uncomplicated joy that a perfectly crafted tomato sandwich brings. It’s a culinary journey that transcends time, offering a taste of the past in every delightful bite.

image source : Basil & Bubbly – The Washington Post/Scott Suchman – Gainesville Times/Austin Steele