This Old Fashioned Custard Pie Recipe is Bringing Back Nostalgic Flavors!


Indulging in the rich tradition of homemade desserts brings forth memories of warmth and comfort. Among these timeless delights stands the Old Fashioned Custard Pie, a culinary treasure that has graced tables for generations. With its velvety texture and delicate balance of sweetness, this pie embodies simplicity and sophistication. Let’s embark on a culinary journey to recreate this classic treat, infusing it with a touch of originality while honoring its cherished legacy.

To embark on crafting our rendition of the Old Fashioned Custard Pie, we’ll gather our culinary essentials and infuse them with a dash of creativity.


  • 1 unbaked pie shell (opt for a deep dish variety for a generous filling)
  • 3 large eggs
  • ½ cup granulated sugar
  • ½ teaspoon salt
  • ½ teaspoon ground nutmeg (freshly grated for an extra burst of flavor)
  • 2-2/3 cups whole milk
  • 1 teaspoon pure vanilla extract


  1. Preparation: Begin by preheating your oven to 350 degrees Fahrenheit, ensuring it reaches the perfect temperature to work its magic on our pie.
  2. Egg Medley: In a mixing bowl, crack open the eggs and give them a gentle whisk, allowing them to mingle and prepare for their starring role in our custard creation.
  3. Sweet Symphony: Introduce the granulated sugar into the egg mixture, blending them harmoniously until they form a symphony of sweetness.
  4. Seasoned Elegance: Add a pinch of salt to elevate the flavors, followed by the enchanting aroma of freshly grated nutmeg, infusing our custard with a hint of spice.
  5. Creamy Embrace: Pour in the whole milk, allowing its creamy embrace to envelop the mixture, promising a luscious texture and rich flavor.
  6. Vanilla Serenade: Complete our concoction with a teaspoon of pure vanilla extract, adding a subtle yet captivating note to our custard ensemble.
  7. Filling the Canvas: Carefully pour our custard masterpiece into the awaiting canvas of the unbaked pie shell, ensuring it is evenly distributed for a symmetrical finish.
  8. Bake and Blossom: Place our creation into the preheated oven, allowing it to bake for 35 to 40 minutes, until the custard sets and the aroma fills the air with anticipation.
  9. Culinary Overture: As our pie basks in the oven’s warmth, it undergoes a culinary transformation, evolving into a masterpiece of golden perfection.
  10. Nutmeg Finale: Once baked to perfection, remove our custard pie from the oven and let it cool, preparing it for its final flourish.
  11. Sensory Delight: Sprinkle the top of our pie with a delicate dusting of freshly grated nutmeg, igniting the senses with its aromatic charm, signaling the culmination of our culinary journey.
  12. Serving Grace: With grace and anticipation, slice into our Old Fashioned Custard Pie, revealing its creamy interior and golden crust, ready to delight palates and evoke cherished memories with every decadent bite.


In the grand tapestry of culinary classics, the Old Fashioned Custard Pie stands as a beacon of tradition, weaving together the threads of simplicity and sophistication into a masterpiece of flavor and nostalgia.

 As we embark on our culinary journey, crafting our rendition of this timeless delight, we not only pay homage to the cherished recipes of the past but also infuse them with a touch of originality and creativity. With each decadent slice, we create new memories and traditions, passing down the art of homemade desserts from generation to generation.

As we bid farewell to our culinary adventure, let us reflect on the joyous moments shared around the table, the laughter that filled the air, and the sense of warmth and comfort that enveloped us with every bite.

 May our Old Fashioned Custard Pie continue to grace our tables, not merely as a dessert but as a symbol of love, connection, and the timeless beauty of homemade goodness. And as we savor each delicious mouthful, may we carry forward the spirit of culinary craftsmanship, celebrating both the old and the new, and embracing the joy of creating culinary treasures that nourish both body and soul.